
Fadix
Forumjan-
Posts
10 -
Joined
-
Last visited
About Fadix
-
Rank
Newbie
-
You took that from Wikipedia. Right? The genocide article ended up on mediation, and now there is an arbitration cases. I've wrote the Ottoman Armenian population entry, and am working in adding hundreds of words more text and refferences in it. And am working on "Ottoman Armenian Casulaties" entry as well. Please guys, vote in my poll, it is really important.
-
I think West and East is more subjective. Kars could be called Western Armenia, while it is part of Russian Armenia. The term Russian here is just to clarify, nothing more.
-
I have posted this poll in two other forums, I just hope to have as much people as possible participating int it, to see if it will confirm what I thought. There was many Ottoman Armenians having emigrated before 1914... but the important is from those dates to 1922.
-
Exactly, you also cite lands lost from Russian Armenia in the profit of others... but those Armenians are not Ottoman Armenians, but were added in the list of survivors.
-
I don't think it would have played over 20,000. The league of nations figure was an educated guess, it took the refugees from Kars and Ardahan etc. as simple Armenian refugees, which was interprated as Ottoman Armenian refugees, and probably many Armenian refugees to Yerevan that came as a result of the Turkish agression of Russian Armenia. As to population movement, the only margin of error would here be the two years prior to 1922, and this is where I came to a 20,000 as figure, this is why I ignored it.
-
Don't take me wrong, I called it Russian Armenia because it was the only way to separate it from what was called Ottoman Armenia. The League of Nations list seems to have mixed refugees from the region, and I find 150,000 Armenians short, so I want to have an idea by using the ratio... and the only way to differentiating the two, is to call one "Russian Armenia."
-
I don't know Russian, I have used a translator to understand what you meant? Is there a moderator that knows Russian and can translate it in russian and edit my poll? I'de really appreciate it, this is a really important poll.
-
This is an unscientific poll, but it could help me to have an idea, I might post this in other Armenian forums, or others could do that as well. I need a %. Please if you vote here, if you see this poll elsewhere don't vote again. I need this, because in my calculation of those having emigrated from the Ottoman, I find 150,000 less than what the League of Nations has found(I find 250,000, they gave 400,000), and I want to have an idea of if this makes sense by calculating the ratio. If one side of your family is from choice 3, and the other not, please specify. I did not post this in the genocide section, because I need as much answer as possible. Regards