barev dzez
Simon and others
ya perviy raz v etom forume. panravilos vashe diskussiya s mashim drugom-gruzinom pra istoriyu i narod.
Druzya, inagda mne kazhetsya chto ya i v pravdu nacionalist, no ya negatov atvetit ili verit tradicionnim armyanskim istochnikam a vapros praiskhazhdeniya armyan v etom regione.
K sazhaleniyu, ne-armyanskiye uchyonniye krugi tvyordo veryat chto armyani priekhali is Thrakii, to is iz severa-vastoka Balkan. Eto teoriya nam ne nravitsya, no mozhet bit i eto pravda. Oche malo dakazatelstv, chto armyani i urarti eto adni i te zhe lyudi. Mi mozhem v eto veryat, no ne mozhem zastavit drugikh verit v eto.
Ya prosto adnu vesh ne paymu. Yesli armyani priekhali iz Evropi, to sleduyet schitat chto vse indoevropeyci iz evropi? etomu oche trudnu paverit.
Anyway, mne bolshe vsevo schitayetsy pravdapadobnim tot fakt, chto armyani zhili gde to zdes, no tolko posle aslableniya Urartu smagli vzyat vsyo nagorye v svai ruki.
No nado panimat, chto mnogiye grcheskiye istochniki tverdyat, chto armyani iz zapada priekhali, i asnavlis v etoy chasti mira. Dumayu eto bil Ksenofon, katoriy pisal chto u armyan (4 ili 5 vek B.C) bila ta zhe samaya stil adezhdi kak i u thrakiycev.
Tak chto vsyo vazmozhno
i pazhaluysta, ne abizhayte nashevo gruzina, nam druzya nuzhni
regards to all
